Crewe Alex 2-2 Newport County 26-27 Review - Cracks

Updated: 3 days ago
Sorry, but I'm in no mood for a review that tries to find the positives out of today's game. Yes, they produced a spirited comeback to claw a point that seemed a million miles away after 75 minutes. Yes, they never gave up, maintained their unbeaten home record and stayed in the top 7. But a decent 15 minutes don't forgive what was a truly atrocious 75 minutes where they Alex were once again outplayed, outfought and outthought by a Newport side that came with a game plan and were minutes away from executing it perfectly. Today's draw papers over the cracks. Nothing more. This is my review of the game:
Square Pegs
I've been saying it for weeks, but for the love of god, stop playing 4-2-3-1. You aren't smart enough to play it and you don't have the players anymore to execute it. It was different last season when you had 2 wingers in Agius and O'Reilly that would at least play in those positions. We've gone from those 2 a striker out of position achieving nothing other than 60 minutes of sprinting and a left winger that seems to want to go AWOL any chance he gets. There is no width in the team, so is it any wonder the number 10 gets crowded out all the time? I feel sorry for the defenders, because they have no chance with the jumbled mess in front of them.
Built For What?
What is this side supposed to be good at? What does it have a lot of? Technical players. What does it not have a lot of? Tall, physical players. So why is it that for the vast majority of this game and most games this season, they just whack the ball long? Why are we watching technical players stand there like statues, offering no out ball.
For me, it's a fundamental issue that sits squarely with the manager. What is he telling them to do? Or not telling them to do more pertinently. Why are they playing this way still, a third of the way in to the season? They aren't banged up with loads of injuries. They aren't coming off a midweek game. So there is no excuse.
I'm sat here writing this listening to the manager bemoan the 1st half, but this is a growing pattern. Why is it that these first half performances keep happening? Why are we not seeing any improvement? Why is this team incapable of playing for more than a half of football? Why do they seemingly need to be a goal or two down before they wake up and start playing?
Attitudes
I give the players a lot of slack. But they don't help themselves sometimes. The attitude of some of them stank today. Yes, I get the frustrations with themselves, with the opponents and maybe even with how the management are using them. But this is an experienced group, Stephenson(one of their best players today btw) aside. Why are they incapable of winning first and second balls? Why are they walking around the pitch looking lost and beat? They are in the top 7 with an unbeaten home record. Yet for 75 minutes of that game, they looked like a side low on confidence battling relegation.
What gives? You don't need the manager to tell you to play in your actual position. To win more duels. To move around more. Some of them need a serious reality check and to actually start performing. Because too often fans like me defend and protect them, as does the manager. Some need calling out on their frankly inexcusable mistakes.
Long Term
The worry I have is, look who they have coming up in their next 3 home games. Grimsby, who have won back to back away games by 4-1 margins, then L1 Plymouth in the FA Cup, then league leaders Salford. If the Alex don't improve and quick, they will not win next week at Gillingham. They will get stuffed against Grimsby, probably lose against Plymouth and then find the rest of December, usually their worst month form wise, to be a tough slog. They have got to improve and fast. Because a mid-table Newport side generously allowed them back in to the game today. Don't count on the likes of Grimsby, Plymouth and Salford do be so kind.
Opponent Analysis
They'll be wondering how they didn't win that game comfortably, as they were the better side for the majority of it. Etete was a real handful up front, Bamba was lively on the wing and their looked like a solid and well organised side. Yes, the time wasting and crying for fouls/free kicks made it a hard watch, but can you blame them? Hayden Mullins has them in a good spot.
Referee Assessment
I thought we were in for a good one after that early booking, but he descended into farce. Some of the fouls he gave were ridiculous and his booking of Thibaut was hilarious.
Management Assessment
They have got to shake things up. 4 games without a win in the league isn't anything to panic about, but it needs to end soon and at the moment, it's hard to see where a win is coming from. Their system, tactics and decisions are confused at the moment and they need 3 points quick.
Player Assessments
Ian Lawlor
Only had 1 save to make and it was a superb one, keeping it at 2-0 early in the 2nd half. That being said, that misplaced pass later in the half almost killed them. He was fine for the most part.
Lewis Billington
Just a mess attack wise. It's the same conversation we've had for the last 12 months. He's not going to make it long term as a full back. He has no attacking instincts whatsoever. Get him at CB for a game or two and see what Dancey has got at RB.
Luke Offord
His worst game in a Crewe shirt since his return and there have been a few recently. He had no business going for that cross and it only got worse from there. He's been a disaster of late and he needs to snap out of it and fast.
Josh Stephenson
Was the only one who could stand up to Etete, he battled well and cropped up at the other end with the crucial equaliser, which did make up for the fact he lost out on the header for Newport's 2nd goal.
Reece Hutchinson
I feel for him, because for 18 months now, he's had no real LW outlet to work with. He's crying out for a winger who actually wants to play LW.
Conor Thomas
Meh. I won't say he was poor, because he wasn't. But he wasn't great either and yet again, he got hauled off with an hour gone.
Matus Holicek MOTM
Much better in the 2nd half, but this obsession with shoe horning into a deeper midfield role is infuriating. His assist for Stephenson's header was an excellent one. Get him higher up the pitch.
Josh March
Dreadful. I get he's probably frustrated playing out of position and he needs a break, but he still needs to do better. He absolutely shouldn't start next week. 21 touches in 59 minutes of football. Not enough.
Joe White
Another player who needs to get his act together. His performances minute to minute range from outstanding to atrocious. That being said, moving him from the number 10 to the right wing to the left side of a diamond midfield isn't helping.
Jordan Gibson
Anonymous and that's being generous.
Charlie McNeill
A strange game where he spent most of it struggling, yet popped up with the first goal after gambling on the rebound for his 4th goal in 7 games. He wasn't offside either.
Subs:
Joel Tabiner
Played on the right a midfield diamond, but he caused problems and I'm asking why he isn't starting over March currently.
Adrien Thibaut
His booking was a joke, but when he plays football and doesn't grapple all the time, he can actually play. A decent introduction.
Owen Lunt
Instantly added a bit of bite to the midfield. Unless there is a health/fitness reason behind him being on the bench, he has to start, as they are a better side with him in it.
Calum Agius
Came on at RB for some reason. Baffling.
James Jones
You did wonder if that late cameo and cross was going to lead to the winner, but not to be in his homecoming.
Overall Verdict
Stealing a point isn't grounds for optimism. The tactics need changing, the players need to up their game and the whole club needs a win, as the frustration over the performance levels is reaching boiling point. Maybe a long trip south is what is needed. Maybe it's the complete opposition. I suppose we'll find out next Saturday at 5pm.



Comments