top of page

Crewe Alex 2-1 AFC Wimbledon 26-27 FA Cup Review - Half Way

Writer: Standing Alone
Standing Alone
Nov 8
5 min read

For most lower league clubs, the goal of any FA Cup run is to reach the 3rd round. That's when the big boys come in, that's when the really juicy ties happen. Well, the Alex are officially half way towards reaching that goal, as they were able to navigate themselves past L1 Wimbledon to reach the 2nd round for the 1st time in 3 years. As I'm sure you might have also guessed, there is another meaning by my review title as well. Here is my review of today's game:


Half Way Line stunner


I might have seen goals scored from the half way line in Crewe games before this season, but I couldn't remember any. They are very rare in any case. There is a reason people still reference Shaun Smith's effort from all those years ago. Well, only a few weeks after we saw one scored against the Alex, we've now seen one scored for them. And what makes it different to Smith's goal is that this was from open play, not a dead ball.


Charlie McNeill, take a bow. He's had a stop start time to his loan, but this goal will be remembered for a long, long time. What an incredible strike. It's an absolute stunner and the only shame is that so few were there to witness it.


Competitive


What was pleasing today was that the Alex stood up to a very direct and physical L1 team. They haven't changed since they left L2, with their team full of giant players, Jayden Stockley being the most prominent amongst them. They posed a lot of questions on set pieces, but the Alex for the most part stood tall and didn't give up too many openings.


League One Opponents


Let's not undersell this win. They stood up, matched and probably in some cases did better than a L1 side. Given we saw only 7 upsets so far in this round(a lower league side beating a higher level one), we shouldn't be too critical of any of the things the Alex found challenging today. Yes, Wimbledon had some chances and yes it was nervy at the end, but again, given the difference in league, I don't mind one bit.


Poacher


Look, I'm as down on Conor Thomas as anyone in the fan base and I'm not alone in that regard. Well, every now and again, he perhaps shows why he's still at the club and why he's still getting picked. He followed in McNeill's well taken free kick and nodded in for his first goal since February. He has the occasional habit of scoring key goals.


His 2 against Salford last season opened the scoring and eventually proved to be the game winner. His goal against Tranmere was a much needed equaliser. This one also proved to be the eventual winner. He gets a lot of stick from some fans, me included. So tonight will feel like vindication for him and the manager. A moment to remind us critics that he does still have some value to the team.


Opposition Analysis


I've already touched on it, but one dimensional doesn't really cover it. You can see why they find it hard to score goals and pick up results in L1. The kick and rush stuff might work in L2, but a level up, it's clearly not as effective. They best pray Stockley stays fit, because without him they are going down. It's that simple. They might still go down with him the way things are going.


Referee Assessment


What else can you say at this point? It's farcical. Shirt pulls on Crewe players, no yellows. Crewe players shirt pull, yellow. A clear foul on McNeill as he's about to shoot, no foul. This from a Championship ref. Good lord we're all doomed.


Management Assessment


I'd still like to see this XI put into a 4-4-2. And I still think Josh March desperately needs a breather. But the players put in a hell of a shift and gave their all, so Bell can be rightfully proud of them.


Player Assessments


Ian Lawlor


Dealt with a lot of physical pressure and made several decent saves. A solid afternoon from him.


Lewis Billington


Did fine until the rapid Sasu came on, then he really struggled. He won't face players like that very often at this level, but it perhaps shows why he might find it difficult to move up a level as a full back and why CB is his natural home.


Luke Offord


Really good for the most part. Lost a few battles to Stockley, but him and Stephenson were excellent.


Josh Stephenson


Seemed to love the physical battle. I liked his ability to bring the ball out of defence on a few occasions.


Reece Hutchinson


Got forward superbly, which is what you want to see from him.


Conor Thomas


A good game from him, I have to admit. I had my worries when he got the early booking, but he kept his head and got the all important 2nd.


Matus Holicek


Tenacious in his tackling and lively in picking the ball up. A better game, although I won't change my mind on wanting to see him play higher up the pitch.


Josh March


He works his socks off, but come on, get the guy a game off. He was running in treacle in the 2nd half and that mishit shot early in that half was surely a sign of how tired he is.


Joe White


Looked transformed in the number 10 role, as he operated with greater freedom. Am I crazy for thinking that a midfield 3 with Thomas at the base and him and Lunt operating further forward might just work?


Jordan Gibson


No joy today, he struggled to get into it, but then when he did get a chance, he was knocked down on the edge of the box. He got into some good positions, but the other players couldn't find him.


Charlie McNeill MOTM


His best game in a Crewe shirt by far. His goal alone was incredible, but he followed it up with a strong all round game where he had a couple more shots and his free kick led to the 2nd. An outstanding afternoon.


Subs:


Adrien Thibaut


I like his willingness to battle with defenders. But could he find the pockets of space between them every now and again? I just wonder if him shirt pulling with opponents is the most effective way to use him? Oh and that foul that got him a yellow was plain stupid. It could have easily been a red. He needs to cut the reckless side out of his game yesterday.


Owen Lunt


Great to see him back after his health scare last weekend. He was tenacious at usual. Let's hope he's fit to start next week.


Calum Agius


Spent a lot of his time on the pitch defending, so hard to judge him.


Joel Tabiner


Same for him on the right wing.


Kyle Ure


What a minute of game time he had.


Final Verdict


In to the hat for round 2. Now you hope for someone interesting like Dover, Kidderminster or Guiseley, or just hope you get a somewhat favourable opponent at home? Either way, it's a nice conversation to have for a side who usually spends the FA Cup 2nd round weekend Christmas shopping. Roll on Monday and the draw.


 
 
 

Comments


Subscribe here to get my latest posts

Thanks for submitting!

© 2035 by The Book Lover. Powered and secured by Wix

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
bottom of page